黑澤明 之 七武士 版本選擇
 

The Seven Samurai SE (2disc / Including Guide Book And Original Poster)

Sales Price : $ 20.95 (28% Discount)



這版好？還是?


Seven Samurai - Criterion Collection (1954)




有沒有也讓熱血的你回想起片中 性格分明的七人之侍 :)



其實說半天是自己想收 :ase
不過到底前者是重發?還是第一次發行阿?
感覺以前看過網兄介紹過但又搜尋不著
尤其標榜畫質有Digitally Remastered
實在很令人心動 :yeah:



FEYD

公版dvd ...是加長版本!!http://www.lib.nctu.edu.tw/Multimed.../VHX002117.html

前者 Running Time : 206 Min
http://www.dvdheaven.com/dvd/dvd_de...251ef597ef2f0d7

後者 Running Time: 3:26:16


根據IMDB
Runtime: 160 min (international version) / Argentina:163 min / Japan:206 min (initial release) / Sweden:202 min (2002 re-release) / UK:150 min (original version) / UK:190 min (1991 re-release) / USA:141 min / USA:203 min (re-release) / USA:206 min (restored version)
完整版應該是206min, 網頁所提208min應該有誤 (雖然是有名的浩然)

http://www.dvdcompare.net/comparisons/film.php?fid=211

提到總評推薦:R1 Criterion Collection
不過R3-K 版初版有送Guide book

另外內文提到
http://207.136.67.23/film/DVDCompare2/sevensamurai.htm
是Criterion-R1(NTSC) vs. AV Channel-R4(PAL) 的評比內容
最後的結論
Image: Criterion 勝出
Sound: AV Channel 勝出
Extras: Criterion 勝出
Menu: AV Channel 勝出

原文如下:
OVERALL: R1
For the full audio commentary and removable subtitles.
The French edition is a 2-disc set with some unique extras, but the subtitles are in French and not removable.
The Japanese disc has a sharper transfer than Criterion, but no English subtitles.
R4 has the remixed 5.1-track. For the Criterion vs. R4 image-comparison, please check this: http://207.136.67.23/film/DVDCompare2/sevensamurai.htm

Note, that new R3 Korean 2-disc LE is coming. Specs will be added, when we have proper reviews. LE has e.g. "Guide book" (Initial press only).

我買的是RI Criterion版本，是我六年多前花了30塊美金所買的第一片DVD。對於這片我是相當滿意。聽專家隨著電影講評的Audio Commentary非常棒，可以發覺很多新見解。
Citerion所發行的影片,DVD的品質都有一定的保證。不過沒有中文字幕。

抓些圖來聞香一下可以嗎 :cool: