PCDVD數位科技討論區 - 有人看過奪天書嗎？(有雷)

PCDVD數位科技討論區 (https://www.pcdvd.com.tw/index.php)

- 影片討論區 (https://www.pcdvd.com.tw/forumdisplay.php?f=7)

- - 有人看過奪天書嗎？(有雷) (https://www.pcdvd.com.tw/showthread.php?t=895431)

我覺得主角是盲人
如果說我都可以說服自己他被槍射到沒事可以是神蹟
我想他府看被搶路人可以是聽聲辨位

在遇到歹毒之前它可以聞味道知道歹徒所在，所以他說沒有肥皂的世界有這樣的好處
在屠殺歹徒之前主角躲進黑暗中(帶著墨鏡)
還有聽覺特靈敏
等等....

一些跡象讓我覺得他是盲人啦

我也認為是神蹟片
因為壞警察不是早就被俄國黑幫處理掉了嗎

此片色調調的太超過了只有大便色一種像看黑白電影馬的

便便若是如電影中的顏色，表示帶血，可能是腸胃潰瘍或是痔瘡發作，快去檢查！

引用:

作者KEVIN SPACEY

+1

我也覺得主角Eli是盲人
所以更確定這是不折不扣的傳教、警世電影

只是導演太誇大主角的神力
(幹架超猛、槍法神準、中彈不死)

而且主角殺人不手軟
(雖然都是壞人啦)

就算是信徒來看這部片，不知道接受度有多高？

有人看過奪天書嗎？(有雷)

後面反派搶到的聖經是盲人版證明主角是盲人還有最後他把太陽眼鏡拿下來鏡頭特寫他的眼睛反白瞳孔不會放大又在一次證明是瞎的電影裡很多畫面用演的給你看如果還要一定用台辭解釋就落入俗套了而他那些神力就是導演把盲人的能力給神化了.......

會讀點字書就代表是盲人嗎?
片首主角打開櫃子發現一具屍體當下就把屍體的鞋給脫了
在酒吧有貓他當下把它趕走
路上發現破車他開車門檢查是否有可用的東西
很多大小細節都顯示他不是盲人
不要說他是靠聽覺
很多事情靠聽覺是辦不到的
其實他看東西跟人的眼神就可以表明一切了

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Book_of_Eli#Plot

引用:

....Eli, now revealed to be blind....

編劇訪談
http://thefilmstage.com/2010/01/18/...he-book-of-eli/

引用:

....
[訪談者提問]
(Spoiler Warning) One thing that I want to jump into is one of the main criticisms brought up that you have to take a leap of faith with the ending. I feel like there’s plenty of hints throughout the film that make it connect.

[編劇回答]
Gary Whitta: Like you said, there’s probably… If you go back watching it with what you know like something like The Sixth Sense you’ll pick up more things. A lot of that is with Denzel’s performance… If you watch that performance a second time you will notice this is something we worked on and did a lot of research on, but anytime he seems like he’s visually engaged with you or reacting to something it’s actually coming from someplace else. He can hear where you’re standing, he can hear where you’re moving, he can smell things and he touches things. He has a tactile relationship in the film… It’s like he opens that cupboard and he drags the dishes across the cupboard, things like that. There’s a lot of little clues. I’ve heard a few people say they’ve felt cheated by the ending and I’ve heard from people who were blown away by it. It’s going to divide people and it’s clearly working for a lot of people. For me, the point of that twist isn’t a “gotcha” moment. Here’s what I feel and take away: if you believe he’s blind then everything he did in the film had to be impossible or a miracle unless he’s genuinely been guided by god throughout the entire film. Picking snipers off rooftops from fifty-feet away with a pistol is difficult for anyone. He’s doing things that are uncanny. My view is that when you see what the book is and that he’s blind that to me tells you god must exist. If not, then there’s no other explanation for how he’s been able to do all that he did. Now I don’t know how many people are picking up on that theme, unless you’re a person of faith perhaps. Let me ask you, what did you take from it?
....

編劇似乎的確是在想拍神蹟片。

另外除了點字書，鏡頭最後還有特寫Eli的眼睛，
編劇導演想說主角是盲人，這點應該很明顯吧。

不過訪談中也提到有不少觀眾不買帳，就像現在這篇討論～ :p

主角那隻眼瞎了...

導演想拍瞎
主角想演瞎
觀察不看瞎

你當就他弱視吧
皆大歡喜
:ase :ase :ase